Pie picker
Which pie should you buy?
Four questions, one pie type, three sellers to try. Every suggestion links to a full profile so you can check the facts yourself.
How does the pie picker decide?
The pie picker works in two steps. First it turns your answers into a pie type using the table below. Then it scores every seller in our directory that makes that type: five points for making the type, three for suiting your occasion, two for fitting your budget band, one for being confirmed open, and one for delivering when you are feeding more than yourself. Sellers flagged "check before you go" lose two points. Ties go alphabetically.
Nobody can pay to rank higher. The picker uses the same facts as the seller directory, so prices and halal status are as of October 2026.
| If you answer | You get | Read more |
|---|---|---|
| Savoury, pastry lid, snack or modest budget | Old-school chicken pie | Guide |
| Savoury, pastry lid, whole pie for a family meal | Beef or steak pie | Guide |
| Savoury, mashed potato top | Shepherd's or cottage pie | Guide |
| Savoury, open or crumbly top | Curry chicken pie, or a shepherd's pie tray for a family | Guide |
| Savoury, for a party or the office | A box of mini pies | Guide |
| Sweet, pastry lid | Apple pie | Guide |
| Sweet, under $5 | Katong banana pie | Guide |
| Sweet, any other answer | Dessert pie: pecan, meringue, key lime and more | Guide |
What if none of the suggestions suit me?
The picker is a shortcut, not a verdict. If the three sellers are too far away, open the region map to see what is near you, or use the filters in the directory to combine pie type, halal status, price and delivery yourself.